Structure and the limits of a center › The Case That Straddles Nature and Culture
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Structure and the limits of a center › The Case That Straddles Nature and CultureSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 8 ↓
The lecture gives the issue a specific setting in its reading of Claude Lévi-Strauss. In The Elementary Structures of Kinship, Lévi-Strauss initially associates nature with the universal and spontaneous and culture with rules that can vary among societies. Then he raises the prohibition of incest. He treats it as universal in the sense relevant to his argument, while also treating it as a rule. Particular rules differ, which relatives they concern among the differences. The resulting difficulty belongs to the terms of the distinction as Lévi-Strauss has set it up. If universality is a sign of nature and being a rule is a sign of culture, the same case activates both tests. “Structure, Sign, and Play,” discussion of The Elementary Structures of Kinship
One response would be to treat this as an odd case to file under whichever description worked best. Derrida gives it greater force. The rule is a case the inquiry needs in order to account for kinship, and it unsettles the conceptual division with which the inquiry began. It is possible, he suggests, that the case escapes the categories that make it look exceptional, rather than being an ordinary fact that happens to fall into both. If so, the contrast between nature and culture is something to investigate as well as something to use. That is a different task from deciding which side should win an argument over the correct category. “Structure, Sign, and Play,” discussion of the prohibition
An example of our own helps locate the difficulty. Suppose a school distinguishes regular classes from optional clubs by asking whether attendance is required. It also allows students to choose some of their required classes. If a student asks whether a course is optional, answering yes because its subject can be chosen would miss the requirement that a course of that kind must be taken. The discovery might make the school distinguish a choice among options from a choice whether to participate at all. In Derrida's kinship passage, what comes under scrutiny is a philosophical distinction that had been asked to ground the entire inquiry. The school example only shows how a case can make the work done by a familiar distinction visible.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!