Structure and the limits of a center › What Can Be Built with Inherited Terms
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Structure and the limits of a center › What Can Be Built with Inherited TermsSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
Derrida observes that Lévi-Strauss can continue to use the nature-and-culture distinction for particular purposes even after identifying its limits. Here the account turns to Lévi-Strauss's figure of the bricoleur, someone who makes use of the materials and tools already at hand. A tool may have been made for another purpose. It may still help with the work, especially once the person using it knows what it will and will not do. The history of the tool matters to how it can be used. “Structure, Sign, and Play,” discussion of The Savage Mind and bricolage
Derrida extends this idea to the language of criticism itself. The concepts with which we question an inherited way of thinking also have histories. The critic cannot begin by creating every term and rule of grammar afresh. Derrida calls that imagined stance of the engineer a myth in the passage on bricolage. The comparison is with the claim to originate a language completely, not with the tasks of actual engineers. A critical argument can work within an inherited vocabulary if it pays attention to how the use it makes of a term changes the work that term does. “Structure, Sign, and Play,” passages on the criticism of metaphysics and on bricolage
Put those two points together in Lévi-Strauss's case. Separating nature and culture might still sharpen a question about how one kinship rule differs from another. It would be a further step to say the separation supplies a permanent foundation for all the questions under study. The distinction could need revising precisely because it helped the analyst recognize the example that strains it. Using it effectively in one part of the inquiry gives us a reason to see what its limits are elsewhere. “Structure, Sign, and Play,” discussions of nature and culture and bricolage
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!