Structure and the limits of a center › What Counts as the Whole of a Myth?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Structure and the limits of a center › What Counts as the Whole of a Myth?Section view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓
Derrida also turns to The Raw and the Cooked, where Lévi-Strauss describes what happens when a reader tries to take apart the themes of a myth. Separating them can make them easier to study, until a supposed part turns out to connect to several others in ways the initial division could not show. Following the new connections changes what counts as a useful division. The analyst can present an account of how the themes hang together, but Lévi-Strauss cautions against treating that account as the recovery of a single unity that was waiting whole at the bottom of the inquiry. Derrida gives this passage room because the resistance to finding that unity changes the form the account can take. “Structure, Sign, and Play,” discussion of The Raw and the Cooked
Suppose one version of a story has someone break a promise to get home, while another has the promise keep them from going home. The promise may initially look central to the comparison. A third story might replace it with a boundary someone cannot cross without permission. The comparison can then take up permission, obligation, or what returning home means in each story. A reader can make a good case for connecting some details without deciding that one theme supplies the original form from which the others descend. The exercise is to follow exactly what each comparison makes clearer and which relations it leaves unexplained.
This raises a question about what empirical material can do. Derrida observes that Lévi-Strauss sets out structural accounts based on a finite set of myths and offers them as hypotheses open to correction by subsequent evidence. A new variant can change the account. The possibility of correction uses a working distinction between the evidence currently in hand and the claims the analyst makes about it. It leaves open the status of the distinction between the discourse about the myths and the mythical activity that the discourse says it is trying to follow. “Structure, Sign, and Play,” passage on empiricism and structural ethnography
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!