Meaning and reference › Why Reports of Belief Are Different
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Meaning and reference › Why Reports of Belief Are DifferentSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 9 ↓
Imagine Ada believes that the morning star is illuminated by the sun. Suppose she has no view about whether what she calls the evening star is illuminated. Reporting what Ada believes is a different act from asserting the first sentence on our own account. Even if we can interchange the names in our own ordinary astronomical claim, the corresponding belief reports can diverge. Introducing Ada here lets us make the example without having to settle what any historical astronomer knew.
Frege's account of indirect discourse says that an expression can have an indirect reference. In the relevant uses its indirect reference is its ordinary sense. Within a report about Ada's belief, changing a name to one with the same ordinary reference can therefore change what the name contributes to the report. The two names can have different senses, and those senses are what matter to the report under this proposal. The embedded declarative material contributes a thought for the attitude to be about. Frege, pp. 28 and 36–37
A useful test is to compare an assertion and its quotation. A person can assert a statement about Venus, or say that a friend uttered a particular group of words. Replacing the morning star with the evening star inside a direct quotation would change the words being reported, even if the reference in an ordinary assertion would stay the same. Indirect speech is a different case from exact quotation. Frege takes what matters in many indirect reports to be the thought, rather than the literal words or the mere truth value of the embedded sentence. Distinguishing the cases keeps one test of substitution from being misapplied to another. Frege, pp. 28 and 36–37
Take two expressions that designate the same object. Put them into a simple assertion and ask what happens to its truth value. Then put them into a report of what another person believes and ask whether the person grasps both presentations. The results can differ because the second report has a different subject of inquiry.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!