What speakers imply › Cancellation and the way something is phrased

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated August 3, 20263 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 8 of 12Logic, Language, and Interpretation
Chapter 103What speakers imply › Cancellation and the way something is phrased
Reading section 6 of 8 · Cancellation and the way something is phrased · 3 minSection 6 of 8 · 3 min

Section 6 of 8 · 3 min read

What speakers imply › Cancellation and the way something is phrasedSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓

Imagine a teacher telling another teacher that some students passed the test. In a conversation about whether everyone passed, that may suggest that some failed. The hearer assumes the teacher knows whether everyone passed and would ordinarily give the stronger answer if it were available. If the teacher is reading the first stack of papers and has not seen the rest, those assumptions lapse. The very same words can then be an accurate update without saying how the rest did.

The speaker can also add “in fact, every student did” without contradicting the initial statement that some passed. This illustrates explicit cancellation. The circumstances of the stack of papers illustrate contextual cancellation. Compare trying to follow the statement that some passed with “none of them passed.” That would conflict with the stated content. Cancellation helps the hearer determine what a sentence requires and what was supplied by assumptions about the purpose of the exchange. Grice discusses the two sorts of cancellation in connection with generalized conversational implicature. The test is evidence about a case and should be used alongside the reasoning that generated the inference in the first place. Grice, pp. 56–58.

Grice also distinguishes implicatures that depend closely on a particular setting from those that are normally conveyed by a form of words across many settings, unless there is information to override them. The garage example needs the driver and the broken-down car. A familiar turn of phrase can invite an inference even before much has been said about the exchange. The fact that an inference comes readily to mind in the second case does not establish that it is conventionally encoded. It can still disappear when the occasion gives the hearer a reason to read the phrase differently. Grice, pp. 56–58.

Wording makes another difference. If an inference rests on the content of a remark plus the shared purpose, saying the same thing in other words often leaves the inference intact. Grice calls this non-detachability and qualifies it when the manner of expression matters. Suppose someone describes a familiar action using conspicuously elaborate language when a plain phrase would have done. That phrasing might imply that the action was unusual in some way. A shorter expression with the same content need not invite that reading. Cases like these help locate whether an implication depends on what was said, the way it was said, or the use of a particular conventionally loaded word. Grice, pp. 55 and 57–58.

An implication can also be uncertain in scope. If two visitors are invited to a picnic and a friend says one of them dislikes crowds, the friend might be suggesting where the group should sit, why the guest may arrive late, or why the guest was hesitant about coming. The inquiry depends on who was discussing the seating and which concern prompted the remark. Grice does not require a sentence to carry a single sharply specified conversational implication in every use. Several explanations for its contribution can remain viable. The indeterminacy is useful evidence in a particular case. A listener who needs to know whether they should move the picnic can ask about that implication directly. Grice, pp. 57–58.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy