What speakers imply › What is said and what is implicated
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
What speakers imply › What is said and what is implicatedSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 8 ↓
Grice connects what is said closely with the conventional meaning of the words. Even when a speaker is speaking literally, establishing precisely what they said can require finding out whom a pronoun refers to, when the utterance was made, or which sense of an ambiguous word is at issue. In the recommendation the reader needs to know which student the writer is referring to. The reader also needs to know what kind of assessment was requested to work out why the letter is so brief. The two uses of context help answer different questions. Grice, pp. 43–45.
Grice begins the essay with a dispute about pairs such as ordinary “and” and its counterpart in symbolic logic. One tempting explanation for the difference is that the ordinary word has additional meanings that a logical connective leaves out. In suitable circumstances, “Sam locked the door and turned off the light” suggests that Sam did those things in that order. There are also circumstances in which the order is irrelevant. If someone asks which of two assigned jobs Sam finished, the natural answer may use “and” in either order. Grice offers an account of how some apparent differences between logical devices and ordinary words can result from what it is reasonable to infer in a particular exchange. The essay does not settle every question about temporal connectives. Grice, pp. 41–43.
Not every implicature in Grice's account is conversational. A particular expression can carry an implication by convention. In the paper's own example, a speaker says someone is English and uses “therefore” to link that claim to the claim that the person is brave. Grice treats the speaker as saying that the person is English and brave, while the connective conveys a relation of consequence. The inference in the recommendation works differently. Its words would be entirely apt in an exchange about attendance and fluency. An implication of poor philosophical ability arises from the fit between the short reply and the assessment the committee asked for. Grice, pp. 44–45.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!