What speakers imply › What the account leaves to the listener
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
What speakers imply › What the account leaves to the listenerSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
Listeners can disagree about what would have been an adequate answer. Suppose a professor highlights English and attendance believing those are precisely the matters the search committee wants assessed. The committee might interpret the brevity as faint praise if it expects every writer to comment on scholarly ability. To decide whether the professor actually implicated a negative judgment, you would need to know which expectations were shared or could reasonably have been taken to be shared. An audience can also infer too much when several interpretations would make sense. Grice recognizes that more than one account of the point of an utterance can remain open. Grice, pp. 50 and 57–58.
The uncertainty is much smaller in his example of the garage because the speaker and driver know what problem prompted the exchange. If the driver asks “Can I buy petrol there now?”, the follow-up can clarify what the speaker took their own answer to be contributing. The usefulness of that follow-up depends on distinctions the original reply left open, such as whether the speaker knows the place is open or merely thinks there is a chance. Grice's idea turns a seemingly immediate understanding into a question you can investigate. You can ask which inference a speaker was relying on, what made it available, and what change of circumstances would withdraw it.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!