What speakers imply › The Cooperative Principle and the maxims
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
What speakers imply › The Cooperative Principle and the maximsSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 8 ↓
Grice describes conversation as an activity in which the participants can generally recognize a purpose or direction. On his first approximation of the Cooperative Principle, speakers should contribute what is required by the accepted direction of the exchange at that stage. That direction can change. A request for the location of a building may turn into a request for the fastest route there. In an everyday conversation its direction can be looser still. Agreement on the object of the exchange gives its participants a basis for expecting intelligible contributions even if they disagree about the answer. Grice, pp. 45–46.
Consider two travelers deciding whether they have time to catch a bus. They ask a person nearby when it leaves. The departure time is more helpful than a list of the buses on that route for the entire week. Guessing that the bus leaves in ten minutes could sound helpful but give the travelers poor grounds to rely on the answer. A long description of a different route will mean little unless there is some reason the travelers should consider it. Even the right time is hard to use if it is delivered as an ambiguous reference to a stop with two departure boards. Grice separates those aspects of an answer:
- Quantity concerns how much information the exchange calls for. Grice also proposes avoiding unnecessary information and notes that some of its effects might be explained through relevance.
- Quality concerns truthfulness and evidential support. Speakers are expected to avoid claims they believe false or have inadequate reason to make.
- Relation asks whether the contribution is relevant to the exchange as it stands.
- Manner concerns how the contribution is made. This includes avoiding needless obscurity and ambiguity and arranging what is said intelligibly.
The labels divide questions the hearer can ask about one contribution. They need not correspond to separate steps taken by the people talking. Grice also considers analogies with coordinated action. A partner helping you make a cake has reason to offer the ingredient you need at that point and to give you a usable amount. Conversation can require a similar judgment about what might help someone who is pursuing a common activity. Grice, pp. 45–48.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!