Communication and social coordination › The background nobody begins by explaining
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Communication and social coordination › The background nobody begins by explainingSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 6 ↓
Habermas gives an example in volume II. During the morning at a construction site, an older worker tells a new colleague to fetch beer and hurry back. The request makes sense against a shared setting. A break is approaching, a shop is presumed to be nearby, and the crew has an informal hierarchy that gives the older worker standing to give the instruction. The newcomer might point out that without a car there is no way to reach the shop and return on time. One assumption about the setting is now part of the discussion. Nearly everything else can remain implicit. The exchange could also take a different turn if the newcomer disputed the older worker’s standing to issue orders. That would expose a different part of the same background. Volume II, chapter VI, pp. 120–122.
This is one way into Habermas’s concept of the lifeworld. The background people draw on includes familiar interpretations, recognized relationships, and abilities developed in earlier encounters. Participants depend on more of this background than they can articulate at once. When the committee debates delivery times, it still takes for granted what a street is, whose task it is to report, and how a disagreement can be entered in the minutes. The assumptions are open to question in particular situations. Questioning one of them relies on others long enough for the question to be understood. The lifeworld in this sense is the horizon from which the discussion starts, and people can change parts of it through what they learn and settle together. Volume II, chapter VI, pp. 119–129.
Habermas distinguishes three functions in that ongoing work. Cultural reproduction carries forward and revises knowledge. Social integration renews the relationships and obligations through which a group can cooperate. Socialization forms people capable of participating in such relationships. These functions can overlap in a single encounter. A new resident learns why trucks already avoid the street on market days, acquires a role in the association, and learns how to make an objection without abandoning the shared project. The three functions tell us what the association has to sustain across years of turnover, beyond physically organizing the next vote. They also give a way of describing different kinds of breakdown. Losing the records that explain an old rule is a different problem from finding that people no longer regard the committee as entitled to decide or that newcomers never get a chance to learn how to take part. Volume II, chapter VI, pp. 137–143.
Shared background can include unjust arrangements. The older worker’s standing is part of how Habermas explains the construction-site exchange. A description of it leaves open whether the hierarchy deserves acceptance. A new worker who questions customary privileges makes the group distinguish what people have done so far from what anyone has a right to demand. A discussion organized around reasons gives that challenge a form. Whether the new worker can risk making it is a further question about the workplace. This gap between the possibility of raising a challenge and the opportunity to do so matters in any application of the theory.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!