Communication and social coordination › What gets people to act together?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Communication and social coordination › What gets people to act together?Section view · Sections in this chapter1 / 6 ↓
A residents’ association is deciding whether to close a narrow street to through traffic. One person brings delivery records and estimates how long the diversion would take. Another asks whether a five-minute saving for drivers justifies making the street difficult for children to cross. The people in the room can examine the calculation and question the priority it assumes. They can also act on a completely different basis. A committee member could threaten to withhold a vote on the summer budget unless the street stays open. The urgency of next week’s budget then gives the others a reason to yield, whatever they think about traffic.
Jürgen Habermas puts the difference between these kinds of coordination at the center of The Theory of Communicative Action. The two volumes appeared in German in 1981. The first reconstructs what it means to act rationally with others, with sustained attention to language and to Max Weber’s account of rationalization. The second asks how that kind of action belongs in a theory of modern societies that also have economies and administrative systems operating at a scale no street meeting could manage. The issue runs through both volumes. People can reach a judgment together, respond to incentives, or cooperate through arrangements no individual has to understand as a whole. Each explanation tells us something different about what holds their actions together. Volume I, introduction and chapter III and volume II, chapter VI.
In volume I, Habermas uses instrumental for action assessed by the success of an intervention according to technical rules. Checking whether a lever can lift a gate fits this description. Strategic action is social. It still aims at success and takes account of other people’s choices. An election campaign might decide how to word an announcement by estimating the effect on likely voters. In communicative action, participants coordinate their plans through an understanding they can accept. The association members can want different outcomes and still try to establish which reasons should govern the decision. Even the disposal of a straightforward technical question can be part of communicative action when people share evidence, challenge assumptions, and use the resulting judgment to coordinate their plans. Volume I, chapter III, pp. 285–288.
The contrast therefore cuts across subject matter. A calculation about delivery times can make a contribution to mutual understanding. An appeal to the vulnerability of children can be used strategically to embarrass someone into dropping an objection. For an observer, the fact that the parties used words and reached the same decision is inconclusive. Consider the residents who vote together after the budget threat. A record of the vote can establish that they complied. To establish the basis on which they acted, we would also have to ask what they thought of the proposal and how their assessment figured in the decision.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!