Communication and social coordination › What prices and offices can coordinate
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Communication and social coordination › What prices and offices can coordinateSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 6 ↓
A modern city also needs thousands of people to coordinate at once. They can do much of this through prices, contracts, budgets, rules, and offices. A baker can buy flour at a published price with no shared view about the most equitable distribution of agricultural land. If many bakers make different choices in response to prices, the aggregate effect can change what suppliers do in the next season, apart from anything the bakers meant to bring about. The coordination takes place on a different scale from the understanding a particular baker and supplier happen to reach. Habermas describes money and administrative power as steering media that relieve interactions of some of the burden of reaching agreement through language. Volume II, chapter VI, pp. 153–197.
A society can be investigated as a lifeworld from the perspective of participants who interpret situations and act together, and as a system whose interdependent activities have effects that exceed their intentions. That is a distinction between ways of explaining coordination. It also helps Habermas characterize a historical development in which markets and administrations become increasingly differentiated. The participants still act within recognized arrangements. A payment works as payment because people and institutions recognize money and the rules for using it. An administrative directive can coordinate staff because an office and its jurisdiction are recognized. The institutions can be held up for judgment even when their routine operation dispenses with a fresh discussion of their authority each time. Volume II, chapter VI, pp. 153–168 and 180–197.
The system perspective shows why a succession of reasonable individual responses can produce a result nobody intended. Each household may adapt to the higher rent it faces, while rising housing costs disperse a neighborhood and affect the relationships on which a local school depends. Conversations inside the school can clarify what the families are experiencing. They cannot, on their own, explain the pricing process. Conversely, a description of the housing market can reveal pressures on the school while leaving unanswered how teachers, families, and students might renew their relationships. Both questions belong to the social analysis, and they require different evidence.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!