Experience and changing forms of understanding › Three Ways to Test the Argument
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Experience and changing forms of understanding › Three Ways to Test the ArgumentSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
First, ask whether the test of sense-certainty slides between what can be experienced and what can be said. A speaker can refer to a particular tree by using words that are also available on other occasions. If an account of sense-certainty only claims an encounter with something particular, the generality of the words will not by itself defeat it. Hegel's more demanding target is the position that takes its truth to consist entirely in an isolated, immediate particular. The change of context and the movement of pointing are meant to make the dependencies of that supposed isolation visible. The important question is whether those dependencies belong merely to expressing the experience or enter into knowing what was experienced.
Second, distinguish acquiring a capacity from gaining the freedom to exercise it. Under someone else's authority a person might develop practical judgment and recognize that a finished object owes its shape to their activity. They can know something more about their agency while still lacking the power to decide what gets made or to leave the relation. Hegel's reversal makes this distinction worth pressing. It explains why the dependent party may have a route to a more adequate understanding of independence. It leaves the reader with a further question about what it takes to alter the social relation itself.
Third, ask how much of the necessity of the sequence the conclusion can bear. If the end gives us a perspective from which the earlier stages look connected, that is one achievement. Showing that a particular failure had to lead to the exact next stage is a stronger achievement. You can use Hegel's own method here. At each transition, write down the claim the earlier standpoint made, what the test actually established, and what the successor adds. Check whether that addition follows, or whether it depends on an assumption introduced only at the next step. The exercise gives a practical way to disagree with Hegel while taking his project seriously.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!