Entitlement and the limits of the state › Wilt Chamberlain's Extra Quarter
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Entitlement and the limits of the state › Wilt Chamberlain's Extra QuarterSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
Part II, chapter 7, “How Liberty Upsets Patterns” asks us to start with a distribution D1 that satisfies whichever principle the reader favors. In the imagined case, Wilt Chamberlain agrees to play basketball for a team on terms under which twenty-five cents from each admission goes to him. A million people attend home games and contribute a quarter each. Chamberlain receives $250,000 over the season. These are figures in a thought experiment, not a report on Chamberlain's real contract.
Nozick calls the resulting distribution D2. If the people who paid the extra money had a rightful claim to spend it, and the transfers were legitimate, what further reason is there to declare D2 unjust? The spectators used part of what they already held to obtain something they wanted. Their decisions give Chamberlain holdings he did not have before. Someone who wants to keep the initial pattern may have to block the payments or change the holdings after they occur.
The question is strongest when all the relevant terms are granted. The original distribution has to be just, the people paying have to be entitled to transfer what they pay, and the permissions assumed in D1 must extend to the trade under discussion. A defender of patterned principles can ask whether the rule governing legitimate transfers is itself part of what makes D1 just. If a system of legal holdings has always included certain obligations, one cannot infer their absence merely because a person starts with a recognizable share. Nozick's example draws the dispute toward the rights implied by ownership.
It also helps distinguish a stable institutional principle from an unchanging list of shares. A Rawlsian comparison of institutional backgrounds need not demand that each payment be reversed whenever relative holdings change. Nozick can still ask which constraints such an institutional background imposes, and on what grounds. That question matters even when people agree that the Chamberlain transaction, taken on its own terms, looks unobjectionable.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!