Fair terms of cooperation › Testing the Argument
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Fair terms of cooperation › Testing the ArgumentSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓
The person who thinks a distribution is just because it arises from legitimate exchanges starts from a different question. Robert Nozick's chapter on distributive justice in Anarchy, State, and Utopia examines whether individuals are entitled to their holdings through acquisition, transfer, or rectification. Rawls instead asks which institutional background can set the terms of property, opportunity, and cooperation. That difference is visible in the position of a child born without access to resources. A series of transactions can be voluntary between the people making them and still invite a question about the institutions determining the child's prospects. Which question ought to come first is part of the disagreement.
Michael Sandel asks a different question in the Introduction to Liberalism and the Limits of Justice. If the chooser is described apart from particular attachments, what conception of the person supports that choice? Rawls's hypothetical parties and actual citizens serve different roles in the argument. Someone might still ask whether some commitments are so important to how citizens understand their claims that an account of justice should start with them in view. This question concerns what the original position represents and whether its abstraction is well suited to the job.
A further issue follows from the scope of the basic structure itself. Rawls includes the monogamous family in his examples in §2. Family circumstances are also among the sources of unequal opportunity he discusses in §§12 and 17. Recognizing that influence leaves further choices about how to assess the division of work and power within families. A child can be affected by public schools and by the time and resources available to the people caring for them. Similar apparent provisions outside the home can work differently when household arrangements change who can make use of them.
Rawls has a method for deciding whether the claims in his account survive such comparisons. In §§4 and 9, he describes bringing considered judgments, principles, and the description of the original position into reflective equilibrium. We can revise a judgment when we find it reflected an unfair advantage. We can revise a proposed principle or the assumptions about choice when they generate conclusions we have good reasons to reject. The coherence sought is a result of testing and adjustment, open to further reconsideration.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!