Fair terms of cooperation › What the Parties Are Allowed to Know
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Fair terms of cooperation › What the Parties Are Allowed to KnowSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 8 ↓
The Original Position
In §24 of the revised edition, Rawls says that parties lack information about their social position, natural talents, particular conception of the good, and some facts about their society. They retain general knowledge of relevant matters, including economics, social organization, and human psychology. They can ask whether a rule will produce predictable behavior under certain institutional conditions. They cannot pick that rule because they know it rewards people of their own social class.
The fictional parties are rational and mutually disinterested in the argument. That restriction need not attribute selfishness to the citizens whose interests they represent. A citizen may care deeply about a community, a profession, or a religious practice. The party must choose without knowing which commitments that citizen has. Someone who later turns out to belong to a minority religion still has a reason to choose a public rule that leaves the person free to follow it. That person's particular commitment need never enter the argument for the rule.
The Two Principles of Justice
Rawls develops the two principles through the book. The wording below follows the substance of §§11 and 46 of the 1999 revised edition. The first principle requires an equal system of basic liberties compatible with the same system for everyone. These include political liberty, freedom of speech and assembly, liberty of conscience and thought, and protections associated with the rule of law. The claim concerns a scheme of liberties; how each is defined can matter to the exercise of the others.
The second principle concerns social and economic inequalities. Offices and positions must be open under fair equality of opportunity. Inequalities must also work to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged, subject to a constraint on just savings across generations. This latter requirement about inequalities is the difference principle. The priorities matter. Basic liberties have precedence over the second principle, and fair opportunity has precedence over the difference principle. A higher aggregate income cannot by itself justify an infringement of a basic liberty or a failure of fair opportunity.
Compare feasible basic structures by asking how the least advantaged fare under each. An unequal arrangement can qualify when it improves their prospects relative to the alternatives. A gain to the least advantaged compared with the status quo does not settle the comparison if another feasible arrangement would improve their prospects further.
Primary Goods
In §15, Rawls uses primary goods as a way of assessing prospects across people with different plans of life. Social primary goods include rights and liberties, opportunities and powers, income and wealth. He gives a special place to the social bases of self-respect. The point is to reason about means people can generally use, without estimating how happy they are with what they receive. The perspective is that of representative positions and the expectations associated with them. It cannot be reduced to finding the individual with the lowest current income.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!