Questions within and about a framework › What Accepting a Framework Commits Us To
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Questions within and about a framework › What Accepting a Framework Commits Us ToSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 9 ↓
The essay makes the distinction consequential for semantics. Suppose we add variables into whose places declarative sentences can be substituted, a term for propositions, and rules for reasoning about them. We gain a systematic way to speak about what sentences express. Carnap's example uses a formal rule that makes the assertion that a given declarative content is a proposition analytic within the proposed framework. Consequently the claim that there are propositions has a straightforward internal reading. This does not require picturing a proposition as a peculiar physical object encountered alongside the paper on our desk.
The framework choice and the assertions it licenses still have to be kept apart. Introducing rules for proposition talk allows us to state claims and draw consequences. It does not make all claims formulated with the resources of that language true. Nor does it require any further metaphysical assertion proclaiming the reality of all propositions from outside that practice. Speakers can be explicit about what expressions they are using and why they think those expressions will help. That is the defense Carnap offers against the charge that semantic reference to propositions entails Platonic metaphysics. Empiricism, Semantics, and Ontology, §2, “The system of propositions,” and §4
Carnap also distinguishes a framework's rules from images we might use to teach it. Telling a beginner how to picture an entity might help them learn to use a term. The picture is a poor guide if we infer that every feature we imagined belongs to the theory. In the case of propositions, using the rules may do more to explain how the expressions work than giving them a metaphorical address. That distinction lets a reader ask whether a philosophical dispute concerns the actual use of a theory or only the story someone has told about its vocabulary. Empiricism, Semantics, and Ontology, §2, “The system of propositions”
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!