What makes something a work of art › A room full of red squares

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated September 7, 20262 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 12 of 12Art, Beauty, and Interpretation
Chapter 142What makes something a work of art › A room full of red squares
Reading section 1 of 5 · A room full of red squares · 2 minSection 1 of 5 · 2 min

Section 1 of 5 · 2 min read

What makes something a work of art › A room full of red squaresSection view · Sections in this chapter1 / 5 ↓

Imagine an exhibition in which every picture appears to be the same expanse of red. One is a historical painting of the Israelites crossing the Red Sea. Its artist explains the absence of figures by saying that the crossing is already over and the Egyptians have drowned. Beside it hangs Kierkegaard’s Mood, the work of an imaginary portraitist. There are also two pictures both called Red Square. One depicts a place in Moscow. The other is geometrical abstraction. Farther along, a canvas coated in red was to be the ground for an unrealized painting by Giorgione. Another panel is just a red-painted surface. If a color photograph of each surface looked the same, the exhibition catalogue could still describe things of quite different kinds. Chapter 1, “Works of Art and Mere Real Things,” anthology extract, pp. 35–36.

This is how Arthur C. Danto begins The Transfiguration of the Commonplace, published in 1981. The joke about the Red Sea comes from Kierkegaard. Danto builds an imagined gallery around it in order to ask what can make one red rectangle a historical painting, another an abstraction, and another a mere painted surface. The cases put two questions next to each other. How does a work differ from an ordinary thing that looks like it? How do two works differ from each other when they are made from surfaces that look alike? An answer to the first question should help with the second. Knowing merely that each belongs somewhere in the art category would still leave the important differences within the exhibition unexplained. Chapter 1, anthology extract, pp. 35–36 and 1981 volume, table of contents.

That makes the setup a test for explanations. If two surfaces share a visible quality, the quality alone cannot explain why just one presents a narrative or why just one is a work. The ability to see the quality remains important. A viewer who cannot locate the area of red misses something of what the artist used. The further question is what role that area plays. The perceptual description is common to the cases, and the part it plays in an account of the work can vary. A photograph preserving the color and dimensions can therefore preserve what the works visibly share without settling what there is to understand about any one of them.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy