What makes something a work of art › What makes an interpretation answerable
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
What makes something a work of art › What makes an interpretation answerableSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 5 ↓
The opening chapter ties being a work to an interpretation that constitutes it as such. In the case of Kierkegaard’s Mood, a single color has a part in an imagined attempt at psychological portraiture. Taking the same color as the ground of an unfinished Giorgione would call for a different account, with different evidence and implications. These are positions a viewer can ask someone to explain. What reasons connect the color to that subject? What could the artist and audience have been doing with that material? Which claims would we have to give up if evidence about the commission, maker, or setting changed? The work’s relation to interpretation makes these questions possible and gives them something to be about. Chapter 1, anthology extract, pp. 35–39.
This approach leaves a genuine difficulty about how much historical knowledge a viewer needs. Someone who encounters the red gallery after losing the labels might recognize a flat, repetitive treatment and imagine several purposes for it. Their attention to the appearance can be careful even if their first conjectures are mistaken. Later they may learn that one picture was conceived as a landscape and reconsider how the artist could have meant an evenly colored area to present a place. That later experience can improve the earlier one without requiring the viewer to dismiss all first impressions. A question for Danto’s approach is how interpretation guides this process, especially when the available evidence supports several readings.
There is also a question about the limits of the thought experiment. If a classifier cannot use surface appearance alone, it follows that a classification can depend on something beyond it. That gives a reason to consider a work’s subject and its history. Many ordinary things also have subjects, purposes, or histories that exceed what one can gather by looking. A shipping label addresses a recipient and a scientific chart presents quantities. Understanding these things requires background knowledge too. A more complete theory has to account for how a work presents something in a way that can be understood and assessed as art. The book goes on to examine aesthetic appreciation, artistic identification, representation, and the use of metaphor, expression, and style. The opening experiment gives those investigations a shared problem. 1981 volume, chapters 4–7 and table of contents.
Danto also imagines people with a rich appreciation of the look of natural things who lack the practice of interpreting objects as art. They can respond to the color of a mineral or the appearance of a sunset. If they were to select artworks for preservation, they might favor glittering surfaces and ornamented frames and pass over things whose significance required them to recognize a subject or a way of presenting it. The experiment grants them sensitivity to what they see. It asks what further learning would make an artistic achievement available to their aesthetic attention. A person can sincerely admire the red in the gallery while still having much to learn about how to appreciate Kierkegaard’s Mood as a portrait. Chapter 1, anthology extract, pp. 37–38.
Return to the imagined exhibition and give one viewer a catalogue. If the catalogue is any good, it will invite the viewer to return to the pictures with questions. How can an apparently featureless patch of red stage the aftermath of a story? How can the identical color stand for the mood of a person? Where, in a very plain geometric canvas, do the size and shape of the painted area matter? An answer has to bring the work and the circumstances of its making into the same account. That demand explains why an attentive viewer may have more to see after learning about the work, even though the surface has remained exactly as it was.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!