What makes something a work of art › The boxes in the gallery

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated September 7, 20263 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 12 of 12Art, Beauty, and Interpretation
Chapter 142What makes something a work of art › The boxes in the gallery
Reading section 4 of 5 · The boxes in the gallery · 3 minSection 4 of 5 · 3 min

Section 4 of 5 · 3 min read

What makes something a work of art › The boxes in the gallerySection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 5 ↓

A more concrete impetus for “The Artworld” was Andy Warhol’s exhibited boxes based on familiar product packaging. In the 1964 essay Danto points out that the commercial cartons and the objects Warhol showed used different materials. Warhol had copies of the cartons made in plywood. The museum record for his Brillo Box (Soap Pads) lists paint and silkscreen ink on wood. Painting a carton and making a painted wooden object resemble a commercial carton are different activities. The philosophical question survives awareness of that difference. If the manufacturer also made a box in plywood, making the container heavier or more durable would hardly make it a work of art. Danto likewise asks why Warhol could not have used the manufacturer’s carton. The real objects motivate a thought experiment that holds their appearance constant. “The Artworld,” pp. 580–581 and Museum of Modern Art, catalogue checklist, items 25–26.

Commercial packaging already carries meanings. It can communicate the product inside and attract attention through color and typography. Warhol’s use of those features opens another question about what the familiar appearance is doing in a work made for exhibition. A viewer could ask why the boxes are presented in groups, why packaging is made to persist in wood, or why the presentation makes something usually discarded available for sustained attention. These are possible lines of interpretation, each requiring further support from the works and their situation. The article’s question about what makes the package and the work differ comes before a judgment about which reading of Warhol is best.

Danto’s answer refers to histories and theories of art that enable a viewer to recognize certain appearances as available to be used in certain ways. It matters that an artist can work with an existing commercial image, that ordinary products can be brought into an argument about representation, and that audiences can follow those moves. The history of art helps supply those possibilities. A similar object made at a time when those practices did not exist might be identifiable in other ways. This is a substantive claim about what makes an interpretation possible. Learning that a director put the object in a gallery can be evidence about its circumstances. The location, on its own, conveys little about the possibilities the artist used. “The Artworld,” pp. 581–584.

In the 1981 book, Danto considers the snow shovel chosen by Marcel Duchamp. A familiar industrial design can support a gesture about what selection and exhibition can do. Imagine a physically similar implement centuries earlier, before it was familiar in the relevant ways. It could be a puzzling shape with a handle, and its maker and audience would have different possibilities for what to do with it. The difference cannot be recovered by comparing measurements. To understand the later gesture, it matters that one can recognize the sort of thing being selected and see what a decision to treat it as a potential work puts into question. Chapter 1, anthology extract, pp. 38–39.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy