What makes something a work of art › How a line acquires a role
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
What makes something a work of art › How a line acquires a roleSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 5 ↓
Danto worked on that question in his earlier essay “The Artworld,” published in 1964. He calls attention to the is of artistic identification. Consider a listener who hears someone point at a dark area in a painting and say it is a storm. The speaker is identifying a part of the work as a storm in the scene. The dark area is also visibly paint. Both judgments can be right. The first tells the listener how something physically present functions in the work. It can have consequences for understanding other marks, because what is depicted as a storm helps determine what counts as shelter, reflected light, or distance in the same scene. “The Artworld,” pp. 576–579.
The essay makes the point using two imagined pictures in a science library. They each consist of a black horizontal line on a white ground. In Newton’s First Law the line is the path of an isolated particle. In Newton’s Third Law it marks the boundary where masses press against one another. Identifying the line in one way or the other changes how the ground and edges are understood. A path can pass through a continuous space that extends beyond the frame. A boundary can separate two masses whose shapes make the edges matter differently. A copyist could reproduce every line while leaving the copy’s user with the task of finding out what sort of work it reproduces. “The Artworld,” pp. 577–579.
Danto’s fictional observer Testadura sees the painted oblong and line perfectly well. Looking closer would supply more information about the surface. To understand the work he needs to learn how someone can identify its painted features as parts of what it presents. The observer’s question is especially revealing because no additional patch of paint holds the answer. A title, an artist’s explanation, and familiarity with the ways pictures use lines can give him reasons to see what a particular identification makes available. Some identifications fit together. Others conflict. Calling the line a boundary between masses changes what one can coherently say about the surrounding white areas. Thus interpretation has consequences others can inspect and discuss. “The Artworld,” pp. 578–580.
The examples also show why knowing the subject of a work is an incomplete answer. A sentence in a textbook can refer to Newton’s first law. It makes the reference in a different way from the fresco. In the imagined fresco, the arrangement of a line across a field can make the viewer attend to what it would mean for a path to continue through space. Someone who knew the title but ignored the relation of the line to the whole would miss part of how the work bears its subject. Interpretation is an inquiry into how something is presented, as well as what it concerns.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!