Explaining consciousness without a central observer › The Cartesian Theater
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Explaining consciousness without a central observer › The Cartesian TheaterSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 9 ↓
A theater is an intuitive picture of what it feels like to look around. You see the far wall, hear someone across the room, and notice the pressure of the chair under you. You can understand why a theorist might suppose that these sources have to send their results to a common destination where they become available to a single observer. That observer need not be an immaterial soul. It could be described as a physical part of the brain. Dennett's argument applies to a materialist who accepts that architecture as readily as to a dualist who assigns the job to an immaterial mind.
The objection is to what a destination by itself could explain. If an internal display contains both the wall and the sounds, someone or something still needs to distinguish the objects, combine the relevant information, and use it to recognize a situation. Giving those jobs to a little observer passes the original problem to a smaller version of the person. The model gets traction only when the jobs are assigned to mechanisms whose operation can be explained without assuming that each is itself conscious. Dennett, Consciousness Explained, chapter 8, §§1–2.
Dennett does allow that information gets integrated. An account of how someone turns in response to their name, for example, might show how auditory information connects to identity, attention, and the control of movement. A particular connection may have a measurable physical location. The claim about the theater is that these paths need not all lead to the same final place or that crossing such a location is what makes their contents conscious. A person can hear a sound, orient toward it, and describe it, with each effect relying on a different subset of what their nervous system was doing. The person performs the resulting actions as a whole.
The Cartesian Theater assumes a point of final presentation that marks which contents are conscious and when they became so. A time at which the brain responds to a stimulus, combines two signals, or prepares a response can be defined and measured for a specific task. That measurement does not by itself establish a finish line for experience.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!