Explaining consciousness without a central observer › What a report can tell us
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Explaining consciousness without a central observer › What a report can tell usSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 9 ↓
A person says a wine tastes a little like grapefruit. This gives a scientist something to explain. The vocabulary might depend on earlier tasting experience, the comparison the person was just asked to make, or a distinction they had learned to notice. Dennett's method of heterophenomenology takes the person's description seriously as evidence of how things seem to them. It leaves open the theoretical interpretation they might give of what produced that impression. In chapter 8 the fictional Otto thinks he compares several words to an experience internally before choosing the best one. Dennett asks how an account of speech could explain this feeling of selection without assuming an inner speaker who has already composed the words. Dennett, Consciousness Explained, chapter 8, pp. 229–231.
An important distinction here is between acknowledging the report and treating the person's account of its own origins as settled. Otto might say that he considered the grapefruit and berry descriptions and found one more apt. A theory can acknowledge that account of how the comparison seemed and still investigate what influenced the choice. Speech errors give the inquiry something concrete to work with. Dennett discusses familiar slips in which sounds exchange positions or two candidate words blend. Such errors may disclose processes that organized the utterance without having been available for the speaker to describe in advance. Dennett, Consciousness Explained, chapter 8, §2.
A critic might think this approach offers tools for examining reports while leaving their felt character unaccounted for. Dennett's reply is to ask how the critic is identifying the felt character and what explanatory work remains after the full account of experience is given. That disagreement should survive a fair description of the method. Collecting reports and investigating their causes is already possible without deciding the metaphysical question. The point where the theories diverge is what an account of those processes could leave out, even if it were complete by its own standards.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!