The limits of a universal scientific method › How Much Work Should a Rival Get?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The limits of a universal scientific method › How Much Work Should a Rival Get?Section view · Sections in this chapter5 / 7 ↓
A reader could agree that a consistency rule privileges established theories and still ask why a particular rival deserves time. An invitation to reconsider a result is easy to issue. Repeating the work or developing a second instrument can be expensive. Feyerabend gives a reason to take such possibilities seriously when alternatives can make otherwise inaccessible assumptions easier to test. That is only one consideration in an actual decision. The questions of which alternatives to explore, how much to invest, and how long to wait can turn on what each proposal makes possible and the cost to other work. There is a difference between keeping open a means of criticism and knowing in advance how much effort it should receive. Against Method, chs. 2–4
Suppose the rival story about drift fails on the first experiment. A failure that can be characterized accurately may show the team what to change in its next proposal. A change that predicts a new pattern can be judged by what happens in a new run. A proposal whose defenders simply promise an explanation after every result will give the investigators much less to compare. Looking at what the alternative makes observable supplies a way to discuss the issue without expecting one fixed policy to settle every question about how long research should continue. The difference is visible only after somebody has said what the rival would do with the first failure.
A further issue is who gets to identify the alternatives worth pursuing. In the preface, Feyerabend links his argument about method to a defense of public control over scientific institutions in democratic societies. This is a political proposal with its own questions, including how people can weigh expert judgment, check the use of public funds, and participate in decisions about the purposes of research. Those questions arise even if all the relevant specialists agree about what result an experiment established. The evidence needed to settle an empirical disagreement differs from the reasons people have for assigning a scientific institution particular authority. Against Method, preface
A town choosing what to investigate about its water supply illustrates one distinction without needing to decide what Feyerabend's entire political proposal would require. People who know the instruments can judge which measurements are reliable and what they can show. The people who depend on the water can have reasons for asking about particular neighborhoods or about periods the first study excluded. Giving those questions due weight might change the scope of the investigation. It leaves the question of which measurements answer them to the work that is appropriate for settling that matter. The example makes clear why it matters to distinguish the standing of a result from the standing of an institution to decide what gets investigated.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!