The limits of a universal scientific method › What a Good Rule Can Miss
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The limits of a universal scientific method › What a Good Rule Can MissSection view · Sections in this chapter1 / 7 ↓
Imagine being told that a new scientific theory must agree with everything well established in its field before anyone takes it seriously. That rule saves people from having to reconsider dozens of familiar observations every time someone proposes an explanation. Now think what happens if some of those observations were described in terms that only make sense within the older theory. The rule could stop a rival from being developed far enough to show which parts of what seemed established should be taken up again. The practice of checking a proposal against the evidence is still indispensable. The question is when a proposal has to pass a particular check and how to recognize a genuine disagreement with the evidence.
Paul Feyerabend takes up that question in Against Method, first published in 1975. The book follows cases in which changing the theory also changed how people could describe what they saw, which instruments they trusted, and what they took an experiment to show. It draws a broad conclusion about proposals for a single scientific method. A rule defended by appealing to the success of science has to answer to how that success was achieved. The history of a practice can show that some of its achievements depended on departures from what the rule would have required. Against Method, first-edition excerpts · Third edition, introduction and ch. 1
In the third-edition preface, Feyerabend says the phrase “anything goes” is an ironic response by someone looking for a rule that survives close contact with history. It is important to locate the remark there. He is analyzing the demand for principles that apply independently of the situation in which scientists have to make a judgment. The book invites a reader to look for the work particular departures from method performed. Quoting the phrase by itself supplies little help with that investigation. Against Method, third-edition preface
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!