The limits of a universal scientific method › Why Keep an Alternative Around?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The limits of a universal scientific method › Why Keep an Alternative Around?Section view · Sections in this chapter2 / 7 ↓
The consistency condition Feyerabend discusses asks that a new hypothesis agree with a theory already accepted in the field. An established theory may have solved real problems. There can be costs to reopening decisions that enabled that work. But the condition gives a special advantage to the account that arrived first. If a rival theory has to agree before people can develop it, an observation that would become intelligible on the rival account may never be made. For Feyerabend, judging the two by whether the newcomer can be expressed as an acceptable extension of the first leaves out one reason to have alternatives. Against Method, ch. 3
Consider a laboratory that treats the drift of an instrument as a nuisance and routinely subtracts it from the records. Someone proposes that under certain conditions the drift reveals a change in the object being studied. The new account has a problem. Some of the tidy results people are most proud of were calculated after the drift had already been removed. The group cannot evaluate the proposal merely by running it against the tidy series. The unadjusted records and an experiment that varies the conditions thought to produce the drift would be more informative. In that case the rival makes it possible to ask an empirical question that was hard to pose within the established treatment of the signal. The alternative can contribute to scrutiny even before anyone decides whether it is right.
Feyerabend's term counterinduction includes developing hypotheses that conflict with established theories or with observations as currently understood. Such a proposal can make assumptions visible that were taken for granted in setting up the contrast between theory and observation. Having brought them into view, a researcher can investigate what measured features or patterns each account would expect. Feyerabend also cautions against presenting counterinduction as a replacement method. Its value in a particular case has to do with how the rival proposal challenges something that the established approach leaves unquestioned. Against Method, chs. 2–3
Developing a proposal that conflicts with an established theory or with what is taken to be a fact can help uncover the assumptions by which the facts were identified. Feyerabend uses counterinduction as a way to investigate those assumptions in concrete cases. Against Method, ch. 2
There is a limit to what the laboratory illustration establishes. Its familiar way of handling drift may turn out to be sound. The alternative may fail to identify any circumstances in which the drift varies as it predicts. Working through that possibility can still matter because it gives a basis for deciding what the correction does and when to use it. If the alternative only repeats that the researchers might be wrong, it has yet to offer the comparison that would bring a hidden assumption into reach. Developing a rival requires specifying enough of it to say where the disagreement is. Against Method, chs. 2–3
Feyerabend also uses Brownian motion to give the argument a different scientific setting. The small, irregular movements of particles suspended in a fluid needed more than a report that motion was visible. Within the kinetic theory of heat, a calculation could connect features of the movement to a model of the medium and make definite statistical results worth investigating. In Feyerabend's telling, that work changed what experiments on the motion could show about the older phenomenological account. He doubts that investigators could have reached the same result just by trying to measure every slight change in the particle's motion and the surrounding transfer of heat directly. Against Method, ch. 3, discussion of Brownian motion
There are several questions one could press about this history. One is whether a scientist using only the established framework might eventually have decided the motions deserved attention. Feyerabend treats that as uncertain. Another is what the kinetic theory gave people a reason to measure that was previously hard to connect to the older discussion. The example is more specific on that point. It asks what extra evidence becomes available when a theory tells investigators how to compare many observations, instead of requiring them to read the relevant point directly from a record of any one movement. Against Method, ch. 3
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!