The limits of a universal scientific method › Learning to Look Through an Instrument
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The limits of a universal scientific method › Learning to Look Through an InstrumentSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 7 ↓
The discussion of Galileo's telescope raises a related problem. A telescope that seems faithful when pointed at a tower or an inscription can produce disputed appearances when pointed at stars. A terrestrial mark can be inspected from nearby to check whether the instrument shows what is there. The observer does not have that kind of access to a distant celestial object. Feyerabend cites reports in which people who had looked through an instrument did not agree on whether they saw the features Galileo wanted them to see. He analyzes how the use of the instrument earned a place in the inquiry amid those uncertainties. Against Method, chs. 8–9
The difficulty is more specific than asking whether any instrument could be trusted. An optical device can have characteristic effects in particular conditions. Judging a claim about what it shows involves working out whether a feature recurs with the object, with the arrangement of the lenses, or with the circumstances in which somebody looked. People can improve an instrument and the ways to check its results while also learning to recognize new objects with it. Requiring all that work to be finished before facing a new astronomical question can leave no point at which an instrument that first has uncertain standing begins to be useful. Against Method, chs. 8–10
The choice of examples matters here. Feyerabend offers a reading of Galileo's argument and the reports he selects, and the account of a particular observer's reasoning is open to historical disagreement. To assess a case, one would have to ask how the instrument was actually used, which of its effects could be checked at the time, and which supporting explanations became available later. The argumentative point concerns a possible mismatch between those stages and the method imposed on them retrospectively. Explaining why a test is accepted after its results become familiar can leave out the decisions that made the test possible in the first place. Against Method, chs. 8–10 and third-edition preface
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!