Understanding within a tradition › Understanding a Question
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Understanding within a tradition › Understanding a QuestionSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓
A sentence can serve as an answer to different questions. “We will wait for the river to fall” might answer when a family will travel or what they will do if the crossing is barred. To distinguish those possibilities, it helps to ask what was open for decision when the sentence was written. The same words can narrow the alternatives in different ways. One reading puts the departure date at issue. The other puts the choice of route at issue. The evidence in the rest of the letter may favor one over the other, or show that the questions were intertwined.
Gadamer treats the relation between question and answer as a feature of understanding. The reader needs to work back from what was said to the question for which it makes sense as an answer. The reconstructed question can in turn put something about the reader's own point of departure at issue. In the example, discovering a restriction at the crossing may show that the reader's original question about travel conditions was too narrow. Asking a better historical question and reading the note differently are two sides of that change. Truth and Method, Part II, “The Logic of Question and Answer”
Understanding a question also leaves open whether a text answered it well. A writer might have understood a crossing rule and still given bad advice about when to travel. A reader can recognize the problem and think the answer mistaken. Gadamer's emphasis on dialogue becomes specific here. Something said in the past can make a claim on our judgment because we can take seriously both the question and the possibility of answers different from the one we find. Agreement about what is under discussion gives a disagreement about the answer a definite subject. Truth and Method, Part II, “The Hermeneutic Priority of the Question” and “The Logic of Question and Answer”
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!