Understanding within a tradition › What a Horizon Lets You See
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Understanding within a tradition › What a Horizon Lets You SeeSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
A horizon is the range of things that can be seen from a particular standpoint. The image carries two ideas together. There are limits to what someone can see where they are. Moving can change those limits. For Gadamer, understanding a historical text involves learning to take seriously the questions and possibilities visible from a situation different from ours. It also requires recognizing a connection between that situation and the present in which we are asking about it. Historical distance can make the connection easier to notice, in part because familiar assumptions sometimes look different when another way of framing a problem has come into view. Truth and Method, pp. 297–98, 302–07
A present-day reader of the letters may begin with the assumption that river crossings are public infrastructure. Learning who needed permission to cross alters the sense of why this crossing mattered. It also gives the reader a question to bring back to the present. Which conventions about access still disappear behind a seemingly straightforward description of getting home? The past can become more intelligible through that route, while the initial way of describing the present has changed. There is no need to imagine the writer and the reader occupying separate worlds prior to the exchange. The letters, the language, and the history in which they have been preserved already connect them in particular ways. Truth and Method, pp. 302–07
Gadamer calls this movement a fusion of horizons. The two horizons are starting points that can be distinguished for the purposes of interpretation. Treating them as sealed worlds misses how they come into relation. The movement can change the interpreter's question while making a difference in the past more sharply visible. A reader who now hears the danger in the letter need not pretend to feel what its recipient felt. Their understanding includes the recognition that something in the situation was unfamiliar and continues to require explanation. Truth and Method, pp. 304–07
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!