Understanding within a tradition › What It Means to Apply What You Understand
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Understanding within a tradition › What It Means to Apply What You UnderstandSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
Imagine that a town rule bans vehicles from a public garden. A court has to decide how that rule bears on a motorized wheelchair. Establishing how the word was used when the rule was made matters, as do other laws that apply to the town. Still, the interpretive task involves seeing which features of this case are relevant. It matters whether the point of the rule was to manage noise, protect a path from damage, or separate ordinary road traffic from a place where people walk. What the rule covers and how one describes the case can become clearer in relation to each other.
Gadamer uses legal interpretation to make application visible. The judge has the practical responsibility of deciding a case. A historian has a different job and still brings present questions to the effort to understand a law. In both settings, Gadamer says, application belongs to the act of understanding. What a general requirement amounts to can become visible in seeing what it asks of a concrete situation. This is an account of understanding, not a rule for deciding the wheelchair example. The legally controlling answer depends on facts and obligations that the example leaves open. Truth and Method, foreword to the second edition and Part II, “The Exemplary Significance of Legal Hermeneutics”
One can see the stakes by trying to explain the rule in ordinary words to a person approaching the garden. Suppose you paraphrase it as forbidding anything with wheels. A parent with a stroller may then ask what counts as a vehicle, a question that was concealed by the paraphrase. The need to answer shows what your choice of words committed you to. Returning to the original language may make you distinguish a broad feature shared by several cases from the feature that appears to govern the rule. The exchange brings part of the work of interpretation out into the open.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!