Beginning phenomenological inquiry › Husserl's Return to Descartes
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Beginning phenomenological inquiry › Husserl's Return to DescartesSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 10 ↓
Husserl takes Descartes as a model for someone who begins by examining the grounds of his own judgments. The point of such a beginning is that inherited opinions cannot serve as the final authority for the inquirer. The project requires examining how something is given as evident and whether that kind of evidence can bear the weight placed on it. In particular, Husserl says the world given in ordinary experience does not have the indubitability he seeks in a first foundation. Méditations cartésiennes, §§1–2, 5–7
Husserl nevertheless thinks that Descartes was too quick to understand the ego as a thinking substance. If the approach has put ordinary belief in the world out of play, we cannot start by treating the ego as a thing within that world, even a thing of a different kind from a body. Husserl uses the first person to inquire into the life in which things are given and the grounds on which we take them to be valid. Méditations cartésiennes, §§8–11
The shift can be tried with an ordinary example. Say that you are looking at a chair. In ordinary circumstances you could ask who made it, what material it is made of, or why it has begun to creak. Husserl's inquiry asks how it is given to you as a chair in the first place. Sight gives one profile of it. A little movement changes what you see. A series of profiles belongs together as presentations of the same thing. The chair remains the object of the inquiry, approached through how it appears. Méditations cartésiennes, §§14, 17–19
It is possible to approach the next few sections as an exercise in separating questions. Suspending the use of my ordinary belief about the chair does not answer whether the belief is correct. It gives me a way to examine the difference between taking a glimpse to be enough, carrying a provisional expectation forward, and checking whether something I expected is borne out. That difference is easy to miss while I am occupied with another question, such as whether the chair will support my weight. Méditations cartésiennes, §§8, 18–19, 24–26
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!