Reasoning about necessity and possibility › An Existence Predicate and a Test
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Reasoning about necessity and possibility › An Existence Predicate and a TestSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 9 ↓
The paper's discussion of existence goes one step further. Kripke allows a predicate E(x) whose extension at a world is just the domain of that world. It is true of a given individual precisely where that individual belongs to the domain. If one quantifies over everyone at a world, everyone in that domain satisfies E. At every relevant world that much is true. Nevertheless a person in the domain where we began can fail to belong to the domain of an accessible world. So the claim that everyone in the current domain necessarily exists can fail.
The example makes the second Barcan countermodel especially easy to remember. In G, both a and b exist. In H only a exists. When we ask whether everyone exists at H, the answer is yes because H's quantifier considers only a. When we carry the question whether b exists from G to H, the answer is no. In a model with that domain change it is coherent to say both things. It would take an additional assumption about individuals and worlds to make existence persist along access to alternatives.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!