Reasoning about necessity and possibility › Why Necessitation Needs Care

Michael BrenndoerferNovember 1, 20262 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 8 of 12Logic, Language, and Interpretation
Chapter 97Reasoning about necessity and possibility › Why Necessitation Needs Care
Reading section 6 of 9 · Why Necessitation Needs Care · 2 minSection 6 of 9 · 2 min

Section 6 of 9 · 2 min read

Reasoning about necessity and possibility › Why Necessitation Needs CareSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 9 ↓

The paper tests a tempting derivation of the converse Barcan formula. Start with ordinary universal instantiation. If everything has a property, an individually specified thing has the property. The derivation tries to put necessity around such a claim and then moves toward a statement beginning with a quantifier over individuals. The issue is how to read the individual variable before and after putting the box in front of the formula.

Kripke uses the generality interpretation of theorems with free variables. When one of these is asserted as a theorem, read it as asserting its universal closure, with the free variables bound by universal quantifiers. So putting a box before the theorem in the legitimate application of necessitation places it outside that closure. In the attempted derivation, the claimed result is itself a theorem with a free variable. Its universal closure places its quantifier outside the box. The two operations have silently traded places. That is exactly the exchange the examples give us reason to question.

Notice how the formal and semantic parts of the paper meet. One can look at a proof sequence and see a familiar rule with a familiar formula. That formula's interpretation as a whole determines what the rule can be applied to. Once the relevant closure is made explicit, one can see why the apparent deduction does not establish an implication that already failed in a particular model. No change to the counterexample is needed to account for the mistake.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy