The reality of possible worlds › What “Actual” Picks Out
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The reality of possible worlds › What “Actual” Picks OutSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 9 ↓
From here, our world is the actual one. From the standpoint of an inhabitant of a different world, their own world is actual. In §1.9, Lewis explains this as a feature of how the word works. “Actual” resembles “here” in letting the location of a speaker determine what the expression picks out. The relevant location for “actual” is the world in which the speaker uses it.
Two people in different cities can both say that it is raining here without saying it is raining in the same place. The difference in reference helps both speakers make a claim using the same words. Similarly, when people in distinct worlds say that they are in the actual world, Lewis sees no competition over which group has correctly identified a world that exists in an especially full sense.
There is room for ordinary restrictions in his account. At home I may say that there is no coffee while referring only to the coffee available in my kitchen. My words leave open how much coffee there is elsewhere. Lewis's simple example in §1.1 makes the same general point about our ability to narrow the scope of ordinary existence claims. We can limit the domain to our world without having made a claim about what exists when the domain extends across worlds. From that perspective, the thesis that only our world exists is substantive. It denies that the broader domain contains any other worlds.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!