Universals and economical explanation › Knowing That Something Is There
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Universals and economical explanation › Knowing That Something Is ThereSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
Ockham also distinguishes two ways of apprehending something. A shepherd could grasp what a sheep is while thinking about one on a hillside miles away. The fact that she can form the thought does not allow her to judge evidently whether there is a sheep on that hillside now. When she sees and recognizes a sheep nearby under ordinary conditions, her cognition can give her grounds to judge contingent facts about it, such as that it is present or stands near another animal. The difference concerns what judgments the cognition can ground. Ordinatio, I, prologue, q. 1, OTh I, pp. 31–32, translated excerpt
In the Ordinatio Ockham distinguishes intuitive cognition, by virtue of which one can know whether something exists and know contingent facts about it, from abstractive cognition, which does not give this kind of evident judgment about existence or nonexistence. Abstractive cognition here should not be reduced to forming a general idea by grouping several similar things. A person can think about a particular absent sheep without settling whether it currently exists. In the passage Ockham also distinguishes cognitions of things from the judgments those cognitions make possible. Seeing a thing's position relative to something else can ground a proposition about that relation. There is a difference between the apprehensions and the proposition for which they provide grounds. Ordinatio, I, prologue, q. 1, OTh I, pp. 31–32, translated excerpt
We can test the distinction by holding what is being thought about fixed. Suppose the shepherd thinks about one particular sheep while she is in the barn. Later she encounters the same sheep in a field and can judge where it is standing. The animal itself may be the same across the examples, and her ability to think about it does not depend on having a thing called sheephood in front of her. What changes is the basis for a particular judgment. The first situation allows her to think about the animal. The second, given ordinary conditions and adequate perception, supplies a ground for knowing a contingent fact about it.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!