Universals and economical explanation › What Would a Shared Substance Explain?

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated June 2, 20262 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 6 of 12Being, Change, and Possibility
Chapter 74Universals and economical explanation › What Would a Shared Substance Explain?
Reading section 4 of 8 · What Would a Shared Substance Explain? · 2 minSection 4 of 8 · 2 min

Section 4 of 8 · 2 min read

Universals and economical explanation › What Would a Shared Substance Explain?Section view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓

In chapter 15 Ockham takes aim at the idea that a universal is a substance outside the mind. Consider a proposal on which one numerically identical nature is present as an essential part of several people. Ockham asks what would happen if God annihilated just one of them. If annihilating the person destroyed everything essential to that person, it would also destroy the nature that was supposed to be present in the others. The theory would forbid the annihilation of one individual without destroying the rest. Ockham takes that consequence to be unacceptable. Summa Logicae, I.15

The argument has important conditions. It concerns a nature that is one and the same across the individuals and counts as part of each one's essence. It also assumes that the annihilation of an individual would remove that individual's essential constituents. A critic could devise an account of commonality that rejects those conditions. Two animals might be structurally similar without one identical constituent being literally present in both. The result is a focused challenge to a particular explanation of commonality, and Ockham has other arguments in the same chapter. It is a mistake to use the example as an immediate refutation of every doctrine a later writer might call realism. Summa Logicae, I.15

Notice the relation between this argument and the account of terms. The argument points to a difficulty for a rival view of what exists. The account of terms shows how general predication can work without a shared substance. Either line of reasoning could be criticized independently. If a realist answers the annihilation argument, Ockham's explanation of general terms still deserves examination. If nominalist semantics works, the realist can still ask whether common natures are needed to explain something else, such as what makes some similarities more important than others.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy