Universals and economical explanation › The Razor in Use
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Universals and economical explanation › The Razor in UseSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓
A useful place to see Ockham's parsimony at work is his discussion of what a mental sign itself might be. He reports several proposals. The mind might construct an object distinct from its own act of understanding. The sign might be a quality in the mind distinct from that act. Or the act of understanding itself might do the work of a sign. For the last proposal he gives an argument from economy. If an act of understanding can both signify and stand for something, those functions do not require us to add a second item to the account. He leaves detailed examination of the alternatives for later. Summa Logicae, I.12
Before adding a further entity to an explanation, ask whether it does work the existing explanation cannot do. Ockham's example concerns the account of signification and supposition in mental discourse. Counting fewer entities is useful only after we specify what the account has to explain. Summa Logicae, I.12
Here is how the reasoning can fail. Suppose the additional mental object is meant to explain something beyond the ability to stand for a thing in a proposition. If the rival has a real case that the act alone cannot do that further work, then the two proposals are no longer equal with respect to what needs explaining. The appeal to parsimony cannot settle that disagreement. The crucial premise is the claim that the act can fulfil the relevant functions, and the opponent can ask what establishes it. Conversely, simply assigning the added object a label does not establish that it has a distinct role.
Ockham is often associated with a slogan about multiplying entities beyond necessity. Reading the argument in chapter 12 gives us a more useful exercise than memorizing a formula. Identify the act, identify the proposed addition, then write down the work the addition was supposed to perform. Only then ask whether the act itself could perform it. In this example there are two jobs to check, signifying something and being able to stand for it in the logical context at issue. If the candidate account leaves one job undone, the reason to cut the additional object has yet to be secured. Summa Logicae, I.12
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!