Descriptions and logical form › Practising the Distinction
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Descriptions and logical form › Practising the DistinctionSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
Suppose you hear that the only gate into a garden is locked. Ask what would have to be true for the statement to hold. There must be a gate into the garden. There must be only one gate into it, within the intended restriction. That gate must be locked. Learning that it is locked doesn't settle the other questions. Conversely, finding a second gate can change the truth of the analyzed statement without telling you anything about the first lock. If the speaker was talking only about entrances on a particular street, you need to agree on that restriction before testing uniqueness.
Now consider a message that says a visitor wants to know whether the only gate is locked. It may report a question that takes for granted that there is a unique gate. It might also report an inquiry into the whole matter, including whether there is only one. Asking a follow-up question can help resolve the ambiguity. Russell shows why it arises by spelling out where the description's conditions enter. That is a method readers can try before they decide whether to accept the theory's account of every particular utterance.
A similar issue turns up when an organization publishes a rule about an office. “If there is a sole keeper on duty, the keeper has the alarm code” can lay down a policy that applies only after existence and uniqueness are established. It does not announce that someone is on duty now. If at a particular hour there are two keepers, you may still want a policy for that case, but you should not infer it from a rule with the sole-keeper condition. A paraphrase that moves the description's conditions outside the conditional changes a practical rule into a claim about current staffing.
Or ask what information you need to challenge a gate notice. If an official says the gate is unlocked, and another says the only gate is locked, the two might be disagreeing about a lock, or they might have different sets of gates in view. Bringing the two officials to the same gate subjects one part of their statements to a common test. Agreeing which paths count as entrances subjects a different part to a test. This is one benefit of stating existence, uniqueness, and predication separately. The analysis identifies several ways to respond to what sounded like a single assertion.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!