Descriptions and logical form › Why George IV's Question Is Informative

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated July 21, 20252 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 8 of 12Logic, Language, and Interpretation
Chapter 99Descriptions and logical form › Why George IV's Question Is Informative
Reading section 5 of 8 · Why George IV's Question Is Informative · 2 minSection 5 of 8 · 2 min

Section 5 of 8 · 2 min read

Descriptions and logical form › Why George IV's Question Is InformativeSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓

Russell's second famous example involves the authorship of Waverley. Scott wrote the novel. If the author of Waverley is just another name for Scott, it might seem harmless to interchange the two expressions in a report about what George IV wished to know. Yet the result would say that the king wished to know whether Scott was Scott. That changes the question. The king could understand identity perfectly well and remain curious about the authorship. Russell presents the example as a puzzle about what substitution is licensed inside a report of an attitude. “On Denoting,” first puzzle, p. 485

Apply the analysis to the sentence about Scott on its own. There was exactly one author of Waverley, and Scott was that individual. The analysis still contains an identity. The difference is that the description has been analyzed into conditions, and the identity appears within a claim about a unique author. There is no separate name-like constituent in that analyzed proposition that can simply be replaced by Scott. This explains why a person can know that Scott is Scott and still have something to learn from the authorship claim. “On Denoting,” discussion of Waverley, pp. 487–489

In the report about George IV, there are two places we can put those conditions. Inside the question, the report says that he wished to know whether there was a sole author of Waverley and Scott was that author. Outside the question, it says there was a sole author, and George IV wished to know of that person whether he was Scott. The two reports can focus on different questions. In the second case you might imagine someone pointing out a particular distant figure and the king asking if it was Scott, independently of any question about the book. Russell uses such differences to explain his distinction between primary and secondary occurrence. “On Denoting,” pp. 488–489

Test the Scope

Try paraphrasing a report twice. Put the existence and uniqueness conditions first, outside the reported question. Then move them inside it. In the first version the speaker is making those claims as part of the report. In the second they are part of the proposition whose truth the person is asking about. The difference can survive even when the two versions mention the same person.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy