Descriptions and logical form › What the Analysis Leaves Open
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Descriptions and logical form › What the Analysis Leaves OpenSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
The description can matter differently to people using the sentence on different occasions. P. F. Strawson develops this point in “On Referring” (1950). He distinguishes the meaning of an expression from what a speaker does with it on a particular occasion. Someone saying the sentence about the present king can use it to try to refer. The success of that attempt may be taken for granted rather than asserted as another part of what the speaker is saying about the monarch. In the empty case, a listener may challenge the setup instead of offering the ordinary verdict that the speaker made a false claim about a monarch's hair. Strawson takes this response to be significant for how an account of ordinary utterances should work. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Peter Frederick Strawson,” §2
The response and the formal analysis can address different questions. The formal analysis gives conditions for an F-and-G proposition. A further theory is needed to say what a speaker puts forward in an utterance and which background assumptions a listener is expected to share. Asking what would make the formal proposition true can still be helpful, even if it doesn't tell us everything that happens in the conversation. One dispute is whether the listener's response gives us a reason to change the analysis of the utterance or a reason to explain a difference in how the utterance is used.
Keith Donnellan distinguishes attributive and referential uses in “Reference and Definite Descriptions” (1966). In one of his examples, a person inspecting Smith's murder scene remarks that the murderer must be insane. The person could have no suspect in mind. The property is being attributed to whoever murdered Smith. The same description could be used during a trial to direct an audience's attention to a particular defendant. The speaker can succeed in drawing attention to that defendant even if he turns out to be innocent. The description can therefore play different roles as an aid to identification. The example opens a further question about the relation between what was said and what the hearer understood the speaker to mean.
One way to see the issue is to give the two speakers different follow-up questions. Ask the first whether the claim would apply if someone different were shown to be the killer. Ask the second whom she meant to draw attention to when she uttered the sentence. The answers can track different features of the episode. A successful answer about the intended person need not establish that the description fitted him. The point of the example is to keep that possibility visible when deciding what the existence and uniqueness analysis explains.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!