Descriptions and logical form › What Does the Negation Deny?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Descriptions and logical form › What Does the Negation Deny?Section view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
Now put the sentence in the negative. The king of France is not bald can be understood in two ways. It can say that there is exactly one present king of France and that he is nonbald. That reading fails because the existence condition still has to hold. It can also deny the full claim that there is a unique present king of France and that this individual is bald. On the second reading it is true when there is no king. Russell's distinction between primary and secondary occurrences allows him to separate these readings. “On Denoting,” discussion of negation, pp. 489–490
Return to the archive example. The first reading of The keeper of the archive is not out requires one keeper who is in, taking in and out here as exhaustive. The second says that it is false that there is a unique keeper and that the keeper is out. When the position is vacant, the first reading is false and the second is true. When there is exactly one keeper and she is in, both readings are true. The agreement in the second case can disguise the difference. A case in which the description fails is therefore a useful test of where the negation applies.
This also helps with statements that deny existence. If someone says there is no golden mountain, a useful rendering is that nothing satisfies the condition of being a golden mountain. That differs in general from saying there is no unique golden mountain. If there were two, the first denial would be false and the second true. In the empty case they agree, but they make different claims about other cases. Russell's method asks us to state which proposition we are denying. The surface position of a phrase does not decide that for us. “On Denoting,” discussion of empty descriptions, pp. 489–491
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!