Consciousness, freedom, and bad faith › How Bad Faith Works
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Consciousness, freedom, and bad faith › How Bad Faith WorksSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 7 ↓
A person telling a deliberate lie can keep track of a truth they want others to overlook. In Part One, chapter 2, §I, Sartre asks what to make of an evasion carried out within a single consciousness. A person somehow has to be aware of what they are evading in order to sustain the evasion. Treating the mind as two people, one knowingly deceiving the other, leaves Sartre with the original question relocated inside the person. Bad faith describes a way of taking up the evidence of one's own situation that allows an uncomfortable implication to be passed over.
Consider the café waiter in chapter 2, §II. His movements have a deliberate precision. He goes about his duties with gestures that make it seem as though his whole being has settled into the occupation. He really is employed as a waiter, with customers who expect certain things of him and duties he can leave undone. The example turns on the difference between having and enacting this social role and trying to be it with the self-coincidence of an object. The job has meaning for him, which is why he can inhabit it in several ways. Sartre takes even the effort to be nothing but a waiter as one of those ways.
Bad faith can also exploit the other side of this relation. Imagine getting a colleague into trouble and then saying that one regrettable remark has nothing to do with who you are. There may be a point in insisting that the remark does not settle every question about your character. But it may also be true that the colleague has heard nearly the same thing from you before, and that your reputation now reflects a pattern you helped create. In the first case, the waiter tries to make his role exhaust what he can be. In the second, the person appeals to whatever they might yet be and lets that screen off what they have done.
Sartre calls the interplay here one of facticity and transcendence. The job and the past remark are among the facts at issue. Transcendence refers to the way consciousness goes beyond its present circumstances toward possibilities. In his analysis, each can be invoked just when the other is inconvenient. The appeal can be sincere enough in ordinary speech. That is part of the interest of Sartre's discussion of belief in chapter 2, §III. Someone in bad faith can attach themselves to an account of what they are while leaving it vague enough to avoid a reckoning with the whole situation. This differs from a calculated lie and also from being simply mistaken.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!