Consciousness, freedom, and bad faith › How Far Freedom Reaches
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Consciousness, freedom, and bad faith › How Far Freedom ReachesSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 7 ↓
In Part Four, chapter 1, §II, “Freedom and Facticity: The Situation”, Sartre examines the kind of resistance the world can offer to a project. A feature of a place can be an obstacle to one person and useful to another. A large rock may block a route if I want to cross a slope quickly. It offers a place to sit if I need to wait. My project gives the rock its significance in either case. Its weight and position help determine how successfully I can proceed. Interpreting the obstacle differently will never give me the physical strength to move it.
Sartre makes the distinction sharper through his example of someone in prison. In the Barnes translation, on pp. 483–484, he distinguishes getting out of prison from undertaking some action with release as its end. The first depends on circumstances well beyond the person's control. The second is what he is trying to capture by freedom. He also distinguishes such action from a passing wish; a project is expressed in what someone begins to do. This is a demanding claim because Sartre thinks freedom in his sense remains even under severe constraint. The examples give us a way to specify which claim to challenge. One can grant that a person relates to their circumstances through possibilities and still ask whether concrete opportunities for action can be too drastically curtailed for Sartre's description to carry all the weight he puts on it.
Freedom understood this way also complicates any move directly from the ontology to a judgment of responsibility. Imagine two people deciding whether to speak in the same room. One knows that the audience will listen or at worst disagree. The other has good reason to expect retaliation from somebody in the room. Each can understand what staying silent would mean, but speaking carries different risks for each. The ability to recognize speaking as a possibility gives us little basis on its own for judging either person's conduct. Any such judgment would have to address the circumstances in which each acts and the pressures the two people face.
What makes Sartre's treatment of freedom worth reading alongside the café is the way each example brings the person's orientation and the facts of the situation into view. Pierre's absence involves a real expectation and a room in which he is missing. At the keyhole, a person has purposes of their own and an appearance they cannot manage alone. In the analysis of action, an intention makes something count as an obstacle, while the obstacle can defeat it. The recurring question in Being and Nothingness is how these aspects belong to a single experience. Sartre's strongest descriptions allow us to see why the question remains alive even if we disagree with what he makes of freedom.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!