Meaning through use › What the builder means by “slab”
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Meaning through use › What the builder means by “slab”Section view · Sections in this chapter1 / 7 ↓
One builder calls out “Slab!” and another hands over a piece of stone. In a different setting, someone might say “slab” while pointing at a museum display, or while looking at an invoice and wondering what was ordered. Each use draws on the meaning of the word. You can also see that a learner who correctly labels a piece of stone has yet to show that they know what to do when someone calls for one. Ludwig Wittgenstein starts the Philosophical Investigations with an example of two builders because everything the little exercise needs is on view. There are a few signs, some building stones, people who have been trained to use the signs, and something they get done together. Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations, §§1–8.
The book, published posthumously in 1953, begins with Augustine's account of learning words by hearing them used as others point or act. Wittgenstein keeps that possibility in view and tests how far it takes us. Pointing can teach a person how to name an object. It can help teach a color, a direction, or a number too. Which role it serves depends on what the learner and the teacher are doing. A child who can respond to “Slab!” by bringing the stone has learned a use that could be hard to convey by saying what object the word names. Investigations, §§1–6 and 28–32.
In the preface Wittgenstein asks that the new thoughts be read against his earlier book. The Tractatus investigated how a proposition can represent a possible arrangement of things. The Investigations introduces ordinary activities where an account of representation explains only part of what is happening. It also revisits the idea that analysis must end with genuine names for absolutely simple objects. Instead of deciding what the simple parts of a chair really are, it asks when wood pieces count as parts, when molecules do, and what we are asking when we say that something is composite. Investigations, preface and §§39–48.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!