Meaning through use › Why games look related
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Meaning through use › Why games look relatedSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 7 ↓
Picture chess, a game of catch, and a child bouncing a ball alone. Competition helps characterize chess and some games of catch. Winning matters to chess, but may have no part in what the child is doing. Games can involve amusement, luck, skill, or a win, with a feature that matters in one case absent from another. Wittgenstein calls these intersecting similarities family resemblances. He asks us to look at what the examples share before assuming there is a set of defining features hidden beneath ordinary practice. Investigations, §§65–67.
Imagine trying to teach someone ten games in one afternoon. You might show one, describe how another differs, and tell your student to watch what the players are doing in a third. They could learn to use the word properly without being able to finish a different task, writing down a definition that decides every conceivable case. This does not make familiar cases indeterminate. You may be able to settle some cases easily and have reason to disagree about others. A rule for a contest or a survey could set a boundary for a particular purpose. That does not establish that ordinary use depends on a hidden boundary of exactly that sort. Investigations, §§68–71.
The comparison with family members is easy to push too far. Two relatives can look alike through their eyes, others through their expressions, and still others through how they walk. Their relation as relatives can have a separate explanation. The comparison illustrates how similarities can cross without a single distinctive feature appearing everywhere. As a philosophical method it invites inspection of examples. It gives us no reason to announce before the inquiry that every concept works this way.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!