The problem of conscious experience › Two kinds of dependence
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The problem of conscious experience › Two kinds of dependenceSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 8 ↓
The pivotal idea in the book is supervenience. One set of facts supervenes on another when the first cannot vary without some variation in the second. To assess an example, ask what you would have to hold fixed. A displayed chessboard arrangement depends on which pieces occupy which squares. The same arrangement can be shown on a physical board or in software. Once every piece and its square are fixed, that displayed arrangement cannot vary. The question in the book is whether fixing all the physical facts fixes the facts about experience in a comparable way.
Chalmers distinguishes logical supervenience, holding across logically possible worlds, from natural supervenience, holding across worlds that obey the relevant laws of nature. He argues that consciousness probably supervenes naturally on the physical. On that proposal two physically identical creatures in our world would have the same experiences, because the same psychophysical laws apply to both. He also argues that the connection is not logical. The facts of physics taken by themselves leave intelligible what-ifs in which conscious experience differs. The two claims can coexist because one depends on what our laws connect and the other concerns what is entailed once the physical facts alone have been stated. The Conscious Mind, chapter 2, §§1 and 3–4, and chapter 4, §1.
That distinction matters for a research program. A reliable relationship between a neural activity and seeing red may support an account of when someone will experience a change in color. The relationship can be perfectly dependable under the laws even if the experience is not deducible from the physical description alone. Chalmers therefore treats the study of neural correlates as a way to constrain the theory. From his perspective, a law saying which physical changes go with which experiences could make a major contribution even if one could still ask why the world has that law.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!