Difference without a prior identity › How Far Do the Examples Take Us?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Difference without a prior identity › How Far Do the Examples Take Us?Section view · Sections in this chapter6 / 7 ↓
One objection is that the attempt to speak of a generative difference presupposes something that differs. You can press that point by returning to musical accents. They are intelligible only in a phrase that already has some features. Deleuze's position does not require the elimination of all features or terms. It asks whether we must treat the terms as independently identified before their difference can be intelligible. The accent case gives a reason to doubt that assumption in one setting. Deciding whether the book has made a more general case involves examining whether its proposed differential relations have enough content to explain their actual effects.
A second objection concerns the use of mathematics. Differential equations offer ways to specify a problem through relations. In particular cases, where a differential equation has several solutions, specifying additional conditions can distinguish a solution. A rate of change by itself need not determine one curve. It would therefore be a mistake to argue from an isolated derivative to the claim that a differential relation single-handedly creates its terms. Deleuze's discussion in chapter 4 puts differential relations together with conditions and singularities. It makes a philosophical proposal about problems, not a new theorem of calculus. Keep the question about the merits of the proposal separate from the narrower question of what any mathematical example actually establishes.
Finally, ask whether identifying a genuinely new problem requires recognition somewhere along the way. The key example probably does. You may have to recognize how an ordinary lock works before you can appreciate what an unusual failure has put in question. The encounter account can allow that much and still ask whether applying the familiar description explains the moment you see its inadequacy. You can test the distinction as you read. Pick one case, name the identities you initially assume, and try to describe the relationships that establish them. If the proposed explanation silently reintroduces those identities as its premises, you have found a concrete point at which to press Deleuze's argument.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!