Difference without a prior identity › The Virtual, Actualization, and Intensity
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Difference without a prior identity › The Virtual, Actualization, and IntensitySection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 7 ↓
In chapter 4, “Ideas and the Synthesis of Difference,” an Idea is a structured multiplicity. In this use of the word, it has differential relations and distinctive points. It does not have to be a thought that someone can picture. To get a first handle on the distinction, consider setting out the constraints of a problem without specifying a final arrangement that satisfies them. The relations can be determinate even when you cannot read off one finished result. The illustration does not settle how Deleuze understands every sort of Idea. It shows why a problem can contain more structure than a list of vague possibilities.
The contrast matters when he calls the Idea virtual. In chapter 4, pp. 207–214 of Patton's translation, he distinguishes actualization of the virtual from realization of a possible treated as resembling its finished result. Imagine two ways of talking about a design. You can specify one finished drawing in advance and ask whether anyone will build it. Or you can work from a structured set of relations that has to find determinate expression in the course of making something. The latter offers an analogy to actualization, where the relations do explanatory work without serving as a miniature image of the product. The virtual is real for Deleuze in the sense that the relations have a determinate structure. They are distinct from the actual form that expresses them.
Patton uses differentiation for determination of the Idea's virtual content. He uses differenciation for its actualization in distinct qualities, species, or parts. The spelling helps keep two operations apart. It does not give a reason to posit a second object that looks like the finished one but waits somewhere else.
Chapter 5, “Asymmetrical Synthesis of the Sensible,” puts intensity to work in the account of individuation. One can describe a contrast after the terms are already established, or consider a disparity operating in a process that gives rise to distinct terms or qualities. The latter is closer to what Deleuze is looking for. A difference of temperature can help you see the distinction: the difference between warmer and cooler regions can matter to what takes place, not merely to how you label parts of the finished situation. The analogy concerns the role of an active disparity. Suppose the two regions were drawn as identical boxes and the labels removed. You would need to put the temperature difference back into the description to explain the direction of the change you used it to illustrate. This still leaves Deleuze with a further step. He wants an account of cases in which the interacting terms acquire their determinate character in the course of the process. Assigning temperature values to already marked regions can make the first thought familiar without doing the work of the second. It does not establish that the book's sense of intensity is identical to the definition of any one physical quantity. Read the beginning of chapter 5, pp. 222–225 in Patton's translation, where Deleuze relates difference in intensity to the emergence of sensible diversity.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!