What numbers are › A Definition of Number and a Starting Point
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
What numbers are › A Definition of Number and a Starting PointSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
In §68, Frege defines the number belonging to a concept F as the extension of the concept equinumerous with F. An extension is understood here as the object associated with a concept through what falls under it. In this case, what falls under the concept of being equinumerous with F is itself a concept. Related concepts share the same number because each is equinumerous with the same concepts. This gives the equality of numbers a particular proposed object to be about, beyond the pairing rule that tells us which numbers are identical. It also creates an obligation to explain which extensions there are and when they are identical.
The construction starts without presupposing the answer to “what is three?” In §74, Frege defines zero using the concept not identical with itself. No object falls under it, and Frege can make that claim using the laws of identity, without an empirical inspection. The number zero is assigned to this concept. It is also assigned to any other empty concept. An empty matching between the two concepts satisfies the condition on correspondences because there are no objects left unmatched on either side.
The contrast between zero and one is especially revealing. The concept identical with zero has zero as its sole instance, so it is a concept to which the number one applies. Zero is playing different roles in these steps. First it is the number attached to an empty concept. Then it is an object under the concept identical with zero. Treating zero as an object makes the second step possible. Frege uses it in §§76–83 as part of an account of how a number follows another. Roughly, if one concept results from another by leaving out exactly one specified instance, the numbers belonging to the two stand in the appropriate successor relation. The full extension of arithmetic is a further task.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!