What numbers are › Where an Arithmetic Proof Starts
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
What numbers are › Where an Arithmetic Proof StartsSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 8 ↓
Frege opens by asking for the grounds of familiar arithmetic truths. We may know the answer to a simple sum long before we can say what justifies it. A child starts with counters, learns some examples, and eventually answers without needing to move anything around. An account of that learning is useful. It leaves a further question about what would make the child's answer correct, no matter how the child arrives at it.
In §3, Frege proposes answering this question by tracing a proof to its ultimate premises. If the proof needs only general logical laws and admissible definitions, he calls the result analytic. A result is synthetic if its proof needs truths about a special domain beyond those logical laws and definitions. Whether a truth is a priori is a separate question. This asks whether its proof can proceed from general laws without needing particular facts. The distinctions are about what warrants the result. They are independent of how early in life someone learns it or whether its proof is easy to invent.
This way of drawing the distinction lets Frege retain part of Immanuel Kant's question while contesting Kant's answer. Arithmetic can yield consequences we could spend years trying to discover. That discovery can be new and difficult even if the proof ultimately turns on general logical laws. In §5, Frege asks whether 135,664 + 37,863 = 173,527 is immediately apparent. It takes work to establish that sum. He argues that this counts against treating numerical equations as unprovable. The fact that the result needs to be found does not settle which premises are needed to establish it. His aim is to examine the grounds of a proof closely enough to tell whether it uses any distinctively arithmetical insight.
John Stuart Mill raises a different issue. Counting things in one place can make a sum look like the result of an observation about how things combine. In §§7–10, Frege presses this idea with the case of the number 777,864. What particular physical observation would belong to the definition of that number? Observations may answer whether the number applies to a particular population, and whether particular collections join or separate under particular circumstances. The arithmetical proof is supposed to explain how a result holds independently of any such collection. Frege's example asks the empiricist to show where an observation would enter that proof.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!