What numbers are › Comparing Counts Before Counting
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
What numbers are › Comparing Counts Before CountingSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
Suppose every cup in a cupboard is sitting on a saucer, no saucer holds more than one cup, and no saucer is left over. We can tell that there are as many cups as saucers without being able to say how many there are. Conversely, if one cup has been taken away and its saucer remains, the original pairing has stopped showing that the two counts are equal. In that finite cupboard there is now no way to pair every remaining cup with every saucer on the same terms.
Frege calls two concepts equinumerous when their instances can be put in a one-to-one correspondence. His discussion in §§62–63 and §§70–73 makes this precise using a relation. Each object falling under the first concept is related to exactly one falling under the second, and conversely. The cup example happens to supply a spatial relation we can inspect. A pairing could also follow a rule, as when we take the disjoint pairs (1, 2), (3, 4), and so on up to (39, 40), and match each pair with its odd-numbered seat. Nothing in the relation requires us to discover the count of each collection first.
We can now give a criterion for an equation between two numbers. The number belonging to F equals the number belonging to G exactly when F and G are equinumerous. This is now commonly called Hume's Principle. The criterion explains how statements about which objects match can settle an identity between numbers. The proposed condition also has useful features. Any concept is equinumerous with itself under the identity relation. A matching can be reversed. Two successive matchings can be composed. These facts correspond to familiar properties of identity.
The pairing test gives a second way to check that two counts agree. Give two librarians two copies of the same inventory. They can cross off every item on each list against its corresponding item on the other list, or they can count the lines and compare their answers. Either procedure can establish equality of the counts. If they disagree, finding the missed line or duplicate entry can tell them why. The first route makes good sense before either librarian has used a numeral to state how long the list is. That independence is the reason Frege can use correspondence to explain something about number instead of taking number as already explained.
When the identity criterion is given as an equivalence, its two directions matter. Equal numbers imply the existence of a suitable matching. In a small collection we might build the matching simply by arranging the objects in rows. Going the other way, a matching guarantees equality no matter how we have arranged the objects. The count is preserved even if, instead of lining up items by name, we line them up by date of purchase. The criterion singles out the existence of a matching and leaves the particular matching open.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!